I asked you guys a just over a month ago about what black eyeliners you love that are a pen/marker and stay all day. You guys all had so many amazing suggestions that I ended up buying a ton of them, giving them a good try, and finding 3 that I am completely obsessed with! I am so excited to share these with you guys because a couple of them I actually love more than the $22 one I was buying at Ulta or Sephora.
I had a few things that were a must for me in finding a good eyeliner, I will say one I don’t love as much as the other 2 and I will share why below, but they all had to hit a few requirements to make the cut!
– A marker/pen
– Black and really black, not the kind that you put on and turns grey.
– Stays on all day long
The 3 that make the cut are:
NYX Epic Eyeliner
NYX Epic Eyeliner – My absolute favorite, it goes on really well, the marker tip stays full of product, and it literally will stay on me ALL DAY LONG! It runs about $7.99 and if I store it point down (upside down) standing up it seems to last a while too!
Wet ‘N Wild Skinny Mega Slim Skinny Tip Eyeliner – This comes in second. It stays on all day really well, goes on super black, but the only thing I don’t love about it is that it is super skinny when I draw it on (hence the skinny tip in the name ha). I’m sure they have to have another one that isn’t as skinny tipped, but besides that this one runs second. It costs about $4.99 which is a steal!
ELF Waterproof Eyeliner Pen – This one is the one that isn’t my absolute favorite but it is literally $2 so I keep it in my car for touch ups! It writes not quite as black as the others, doesn’t last quite as long, but my biggest problem with it is I feel like it dries out pretty quick… but then again it is only $2 so what else can you expect ha.
I hope this helps you to find an affordable black eyeliner that works just as good if not better than all the ones that cost $20 and up!